The Disciplinary Revolution 在线电子书 图书标签: 历史社会学 社会学 政治学 宗教 社会理论 比较政治 历史 国家建设
发表于2025-01-22
The Disciplinary Revolution 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2025
有时候会觉得社会科学或社会科学式的论点还挺漂亮的。 能在一本篇幅不大的书中回应国家起源这一问题着实不易,尤其此书巧妙地勾连了韦伯与福柯,并且提出国家起源除资产阶级革命、军事革命外的第三重可能,即“纪律”革命或“规训”革命这一在社会文化和国家机制共同起作用的一系列创新与变化。必须承认这一本书着实很有启发性,除韦伯与福柯观点的勾连外,其中比较吸引我的另一点是,(在最广阔的意义上说,)对于在新文化史以及from bottom up的对文化的“深描”之后如何重新宏观地考虑文化与政治之间的关系这一经典命题。这样说可能过于泛泛,这本书目标或许也不是这一任务,不过确实比较吸引我开开脑洞。要说缺点可能还是篇幅还短,不够深不够有说服力,以及对于韦伯福柯的引用有过度诠释并在此基础上建立自己的观点的嫌疑。
评分作者的写作文风倒真的是非常美国:一二三四点一点一点讲,每章intro总结一遍结尾再总结一遍。
评分所有社会科学学生都应该认真读一下这本书,即使不是做比较历史分析的,因为此书是逻辑环环相扣、文笔清晰有力的典范之作。中译本应该快出版了,而且据译者学生反映翻译质量不错。
评分一刷。
评分欧洲史尤其是欧洲宗教史不熟,不敢随便打星。大致的意见是补充马克思主义和Tilly那种对国家形成持经济资源或军事动员、自上而下、功能式的观点,认为欧洲宗教转变、尤其是新教加尔文宗所产生的“社会规训”转型,自下而上地用“类官僚”模式规范日常生活,带来更多的“文明”成分,也提供了一种非国家强制性的社会管理手段。同样的资源,也可以自上而下地为社会精英提供了“协助上帝的救赎”而大规模实施经济社会改造计划的精神资源,并为警察国家制度提供借鉴。作者的文献调查认为,在低地国家和早期普鲁士加尔文宗的精神影响绝非先前理论所称是“剩余变量”,从济贫机制转型为穷人的集中管理救济,到普鲁士军队的苛刻军纪,乃至当代欧洲福利国家的分类,都有宗教影响。而加尔文宗比路德宗更苛严的教规和组织,也表明宗教影响可以比较研究。
Philip S. Gorski is a professor of sociology at Yale University.
Philip S. Gorski (Ph.D. University of California, Berkeley 1996) is a comparative-historical sociologist with strong interests in theory and methods and in modern and early modern Europe. His empirical work focuses on topics such as state-formation, nationalism, revolution, economic development and secularization with particular attention to the interaction of religion and politics. Other current interests include the philosophy and methodology of the social sciences and the nature and role of rationality in social life. Among his recent publications are The Disciplinary Revolution: Calvinism and the Growth of State Power in Early Modern Europe (Chicago, 2003); Max Weber’s Economy and Society: A Critical Companion (Stanford, 2004); and “The Poverty of Deductivism: A Constructive Realist Model of Sociological Explanation,” Sociological Methodology, 2004.
What explains the rapid growth of state power in early modern Europe? While most scholars have pointed to the impact of military or capitalist revolutions, Philip S. Gorski argues instead for the importance of a disciplinary revolution unleashed by the Reformation. By refining and diffusing a variety of disciplinary techniques and strategies, such as communal surveillance, control through incarceration, and bureaucratic office-holding, Calvin and his followers created an infrastructure of religious governance and social control that served as a model for the rest of Europe—and the world.
Table of Contents
Preface and Acknowledgments
Introduction
1. Body and Soul: Calvinism, Discipline, and State Power in Early Modern Europe
2. Disciplinary Revolution from below in the Low Countries
3. Disciplinary Revolution from above in Brandenburg-Prussia
4. Social Disciplining in Comparative Perspective
Conclusion
Notes
Bibliography
Index
评分
评分
评分
评分
The Disciplinary Revolution 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2025