Openness, Secrecy, Authorship 在線電子書 圖書標籤: summer hissci author Knowledge Art&Science
發表於2024-11-09
Openness, Secrecy, Authorship 在線電子書 pdf 下載 txt下載 epub 下載 mobi 下載 2024
3.5星: 方法上是有欠缺的(預設在曆史中固定不變的概念,然後去相應文本中找對應的錶達,最終呈現的圖景其實是相對扁平的,雖然openness的確是一個思想史長時段都值得探討的問題),篇章布局也不太成功(大多數案例呈現其實並沒有什麼深入的分析,而隻是蜻蜓點水,幾乎每個案例都能找到更有趣的專題研究),唯一比較有價值的是整體框架的搭建,尤其是結尾談到techne要進入episteme必須先與praxis結盟,中世紀行會經濟和都市發展如何促成瞭對技藝産權化的理解,以及文字論著作為不同群體間知識往來的中介,但細部的證據支撐其實是有些薄弱的。
評分lucid writing style; hints on how to do historical analysis on how technical and craft knowledge interacted with the learned tradition
評分3.5星: 方法上是有欠缺的(預設在曆史中固定不變的概念,然後去相應文本中找對應的錶達,最終呈現的圖景其實是相對扁平的,雖然openness的確是一個思想史長時段都值得探討的問題),篇章布局也不太成功(大多數案例呈現其實並沒有什麼深入的分析,而隻是蜻蜓點水,幾乎每個案例都能找到更有趣的專題研究),唯一比較有價值的是整體框架的搭建,尤其是結尾談到techne要進入episteme必須先與praxis結盟,中世紀行會經濟和都市發展如何促成瞭對技藝産權化的理解,以及文字論著作為不同群體間知識往來的中介,但細部的證據支撐其實是有些薄弱的。
評分lucid writing style; hints on how to do historical analysis on how technical and craft knowledge interacted with the learned tradition
評分3.5星: 方法上是有欠缺的(預設在曆史中固定不變的概念,然後去相應文本中找對應的錶達,最終呈現的圖景其實是相對扁平的,雖然openness的確是一個思想史長時段都值得探討的問題),篇章布局也不太成功(大多數案例呈現其實並沒有什麼深入的分析,而隻是蜻蜓點水,幾乎每個案例都能找到更有趣的專題研究),唯一比較有價值的是整體框架的搭建,尤其是結尾談到techne要進入episteme必須先與praxis結盟,中世紀行會經濟和都市發展如何促成瞭對技藝産權化的理解,以及文字論著作為不同群體間知識往來的中介,但細部的證據支撐其實是有些薄弱的。
In today's world of intellectual property disputes, industrial espionage, and book signings by famous authors, one easily loses sight of the historical nature of the attribution and ownership of texts. In Openness, Secrecy, Authorship: Technical Arts and the Culture of Knowledge from Antiquity to the Renaissance, Pamela Long combines intellectual history with the history of science and technology to explore the culture of authorship. Using classical Greek as well as medieval and Renaissance European examples, Long traces the definitions, limitations, and traditions of intellectual and scientific creation and attribution. She examines these attitudes as they pertain to the technical and the practical. Although Long's study follows a chronological development, this is not merely a general work. Long is able to examine events and sources within their historical context and locale. By looking at Aristotelian ideas of Praxis, Techne, and Episteme. She explains the tension between craft and ideas, authors and producers. She discusses, with solid research and clear prose, the rise, wane, and resurgence of priority in the crediting and lionizing of authors. Long illuminates the creation and re-creation of ideas like "trade secrets," "plagiarism," "mechanical arts," and "scribal culture." Her historical study complicates prevailing assumptions while inviting a closer look at issues that define so much of our society and thought to this day. She argues that "a useful working definition of authorship permits a gradation of meaning between the poles of authority and originality," and guides us through the term's nuances with clarity rarely matched in a historical study.
評分
評分
評分
評分
Openness, Secrecy, Authorship 在線電子書 pdf 下載 txt下載 epub 下載 mobi 下載 2024