Cherishing Men from Afar 在线电子书 图书标签:
发表于2024-11-10
Cherishing Men from Afar 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2024
資格考讀物
评分材料及其解读问题在吵架中被挖掘探讨得差不多了,列文森奖发给他想必也不是这些原因。上世纪九十年代中期正是包括史学理论在内“炫技”吃香的时候,放现在估计会和新清史对接地更紧密——我认为后现代史学的危险在本作中体现得淋漓尽致,那就是自觉不自觉地滑向相对主义:清朝没那么落后,英帝没那么文明,写作要力图避免价值和立场判断。没错,这些都很有道理,可是有什么卵用?历史学家可以不带价值判断,历史本身也可以?如果是这样,那它对一些国家也真是太不友好甚至到了残酷无情的地步
评分資格考讀物
评分材料及其解读问题在吵架中被挖掘探讨得差不多了,列文森奖发给他想必也不是这些原因。上世纪九十年代中期正是包括史学理论在内“炫技”吃香的时候,放现在估计会和新清史对接地更紧密——我认为后现代史学的危险在本作中体现得淋漓尽致,那就是自觉不自觉地滑向相对主义:清朝没那么落后,英帝没那么文明,写作要力图避免价值和立场判断。没错,这些都很有道理,可是有什么卵用?历史学家可以不带价值判断,历史本身也可以?如果是这样,那它对一些国家也真是太不友好甚至到了残酷无情的地步
评分材料及其解读问题在吵架中被挖掘探讨得差不多了,列文森奖发给他想必也不是这些原因。上世纪九十年代中期正是包括史学理论在内“炫技”吃香的时候,放现在估计会和新清史对接地更紧密——我认为后现代史学的危险在本作中体现得淋漓尽致,那就是自觉不自觉地滑向相对主义:清朝没那么落后,英帝没那么文明,写作要力图避免价值和立场判断。没错,这些都很有道理,可是有什么卵用?历史学家可以不带价值判断,历史本身也可以?如果是这样,那它对一些国家也真是太不友好甚至到了残酷无情的地步
James L. Hevia is Assistant Professor of History at North Carolina AT&T University. He is Associate Editor of positions: east asia cultures critique.
In the late eighteenth century two expansive Eurasian empires met formally for the first time--the Manchu or Qing dynasty of China and the maritime empire of Great Britain. The occasion was the mission of Lord Macartney, sent by the British crown and sponsored by the East India Company, to the court of the Qianlong emperor. "Cherishing Men from Afar" looks at the initial confrontation between these two empires from a historical perspective informed by the insights of contemporary postcolonial criticism and cultural studies.
The history of this encounter, like that of most colonial and imperial encounters, has traditionally been told from the Europeans' point of view. In this book, James L. Hevia consults Chinese sources--many previously untranslated--for a broader sense of what Qing court officials understood; and considers these documents in light of a sophisticated anthropological understanding of Qing ritual processes and expectations. He also reexamines the more familiar British accounts in the context of recent critiques of orientalism and work on the development of the bourgeois subject. Hevia's reading of these sources reveals the logics of two discrete imperial formations, not so much impaired by the cultural misunderstandings that have historically been attributed to their meeting, but animated by differing ideas about constructing relations of sovereignty and power. His examination of Chinese and English-language scholarly treatments of this event, both historical and contemporary, sheds new light on the place of the Macartney mission in the dynamics of colonial and imperial encounters.
上William Rowe做presentation用,包括了后来周锡瑞、艾尔曼胡志德和何伟亚几人就此书争论的文章总结。 James Hevia, Cherishing Men from Afar: Qing Guest Ritual and the Macartney Embassy of 1793 Duke University Press, 1995 ---Levenson Book Prize, 1997 (Associatio...
评分 评分1793年马嘎尔尼(George Macartney)使华事件是中国对外关系史上的标志性事件。后人对其的解读也成为一个热点的研究领域。传统上的看法或多或少都受到费正清“冲击-回应”以及“朝贡体制”观点的影响。而何伟亚(James L. Hevia)的《怀柔远人》正是对此类观点的一种回应与反...
评分《怀柔远人》读书报告 一、内容综述: 在序言中,罗志田老师指出了何亚伟贯穿全文的两个新认识路径:1、“以满清皇室为最高君主的多主制。”和2、“清代的宾礼”。而“怀柔远人”这一观念即是礼仪的核心。作者认为清廷正是借助礼仪来与其他强势国家建立关系。全书研...
评分“1911年清朝垮台之后,中华民国政府似乎毫不犹豫就接受了北大西洋帝国主义强国规定的外交形式。同时,马嘎尔尼使团和磕头问题也不再是强大的亚洲帝国之间的现实的政治议题,而终于成为历史。” 把一切行为两分的阐释模式,如“死气沉沉的东方与生机勃勃的西方”很难不说这也是...
Cherishing Men from Afar 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2024