Body in Question 在線電子書 圖書標籤: 電影 薑文 謝柏柯 評論 論文 藝術評論 藝術史 藝
發表於2024-11-22
Body in Question 在線電子書 pdf 下載 txt下載 epub 下載 mobi 下載 2024
西方的視角看薑文,讀解自然比體製內人狠辣精準的多;有些對於曆史更客觀的認識,也存在對現實媒體主義的理解偏差;讀瞭哈佛圖書館的自帶作者留言贈書版…裝幀印刷極棒的書,好想收一本
評分《鬼子來瞭》部分:1. 說得好聽點是文章從cinematic style到thematic interpretation、historical/cultural/social investigation麵麵俱到,不好聽點就是邏輯跳躍、缺乏中心論點(先講薑文這部的攝影如何在新中國強調contrivance的攝影中獨樹一幟到電影中的animal和中國人的racism blabla);2. 強烈不認同文章最後說戰爭隻是situational的觀點,講真,拿一個七十年代的心理學/行為學實驗做支撐真的有說服力嗎?實驗適用的是個individual層麵上的問題,而戰爭顯然不是;3. 對電影內容的復述太囉嗦,而且還有幾處有誤;4. 您08年的書怎麼不講薑文在《鬼》後其實還拍瞭電影呢??
評分《陽光》強奸戲:“想象她曾渴望但現在背叛瞭他,馬小軍將米蘭視作羞恥物品,是他構建的神話在炎熱糟糕的夏天的破裂。後來證明強大的是米蘭,沒能讓馬小軍推倒,正如D順利渡過瞭那一年的青年動蕩。後者同樣以對身體政治的真誠欲求開始,卻以妄圖進入國傢內部聖域的暴力失敗終結。”然後就是《陽光》彩色變黑白,和《鬼子》黑白變彩色的發現吧。套中國傳統和到處引作品感覺還蠻不爽的。
評分《鬼子來瞭》部分:1. 說得好聽點是文章從cinematic style到thematic interpretation、historical/cultural/social investigation麵麵俱到,不好聽點就是邏輯跳躍、缺乏中心論點(先講薑文這部的攝影如何在新中國強調contrivance的攝影中獨樹一幟到電影中的animal和中國人的racism blabla);2. 強烈不認同文章最後說戰爭隻是situational的觀點,講真,拿一個七十年代的心理學/行為學實驗做支撐真的有說服力嗎?實驗適用的是個individual層麵上的問題,而戰爭顯然不是;3. 對電影內容的復述太囉嗦,而且還有幾處有誤;4. 您08年的書怎麼不講薑文在《鬼》後其實還拍瞭電影呢??
評分西方視角的獨特之處和偏見都不可避免。很懷疑作者懂不懂中文,以西方對中國研究的文獻為基礎理解中國,得到的無非是想象中的東方
In the Heat of the Sun and Devils on the Doorstep are two of the finest and most honored Chinese films ever made. Body in Question is the first book to thoroughly examine these groundbreaking works and one of the first books in English to study individual Chinese films in depth.
These two award-winning films by renowned director-actor Jiang Wen and cinematographer Gu Changwei are unsurpassed in China for their exquisite attention to realistic detail, their stylistic range, their emotional breadth, and their razor-like commentary on contemporary China. In scenes that range from hilarious to horrific, China's ruling elite and its complicated relationship with Japan are subjected to the filmmakers' ironic treatment and profound concern with social justice. In the Heat of the Sun has become unavailable, and Devils on the Doorstep has been suppressed by the Chinese government. Jerome Silbergeld gives these two important films careful and extended study in Body in Question. He uses cinema and photography, political history, anthropology and philosophy, Chinese rhetorical traditions, and concepts of justice to explore the films' visual complexity and intellectual force, providing a unique look at the artistry and pressing concerns of Chinese cinema today. An accompanying DVD includes major clips from both films.
評分
評分
評分
評分
Body in Question 在線電子書 pdf 下載 txt下載 epub 下載 mobi 下載 2024