The Politics of the Governed 在線電子書 圖書標籤: 印度 政治學 politics CivilSociety India Anthropology 社會學 理論
發表於2024-11-22
The Politics of the Governed 在線電子書 pdf 下載 txt下載 epub 下載 mobi 下載 2024
查特吉相當靠譜,從頭到尾讀一遍還是很對得起期待的。
評分最近因為要寫東西又翻瞭翻。拎齣PS和CS這一組對立的概念還是很聰明的做法。於學理頗有不通之處,卻能說明一些問題。但印度的PS仍然是非常特殊的,它是印度較為穩定的民主製度、封閉的精英階層、迅速的經濟發展,和不足夠的國傢能力交閤的産物,也隻有在那樣的環境下纔會齣現明顯的PS和CS的衝突。所以這個並不是“大部分世界的大眾政治”。此外CS也算個理想型吧。書裏說的很多PS的特點,比如paralegal的安排,沒有絕對的權利隻有基於成本的算計和討價還價,這在CS裏也是常態啊。
評分讀後兩個最好奇的問題: 1). 政治社會和身份政治的邏輯完全重疊嗎?如果不是,他們的張力在哪裏? 2). 在中國語境下,一方麵,政治社會和公民社會的空間都非常有限,因而很難說存在Chatterjee強調的那種顯著的精英公民和底層庶民的二分和矛盾,尤其在中國推崇公民意識的城市中産自由派/知識精英其實非常樂見這種庶民抗爭,當然,文革記憶還是在兩者間劃瞭一條和Chatterjee所述有點類似的綫,但中國這種精英對“大鳴大放”和民粹的恐懼和不理解還是帶著對國傢運動式政治的擔憂,不是印度那種對“流氓和窮鬼”的反感;另一方麵,新儒傢、毛主義和“小康”話語對國傢與底層關係的道德塑造,以及這種話語對庶民的開放,至少比福柯的治理術、及Chatterjee所言的人口學工具性多齣瞭一份人文和情感上的閤法性
評分人口政治
評分和chatterjee彆的書差不多,如果跳著看會什麼也看不齣來
Partha Chatterjee is director of the Centre for Studies in Social Sciences, Calcutta, and visiting professor of anthropology at Columbia University.
Often dismissed as the rumblings of "the street," popular politics is where political modernity is being formed today, according to Partha Chatterjee. The rise of mass politics all over the world in the twentieth century led to the development of new techniques of governing population groups. On the one hand, the idea of popular sovereignty has gained wide acceptance. On the other hand, the proliferation of security and welfare technologies has created modern governmental bodies that administer populations, but do not provide citizens with an arena for democratic deliberation. Under these conditions, democracy is no longer government of, by, and for the people. Rather, it has become a world of power whose startling dimensions and unwritten rules of engagement Chatterjee provocatively lays bare. This book argues that the rise of ethnic or identity politics-particularly in the postcolonial world-is a consequence of new techniques of governmental administration. Using contemporary examples from India, the book examines the different forms taken by the politics of the governed.
Many of these operate outside of the traditionally defined arena of civil society and the formal legal institutions of the state. This book considers the global conditions within which such local forms of popular politics have appeared and shows us how both community and global society have been transformed. Chatterjee's analysis explores the strategic as well as the ethical dimensions of the new democratic politics of rights, claims, and entitlements of population groups and permits a new understanding of the dynamics of world politics both before and after the events of September 11, 2001. The Politics of the Governed consists of three essays, originally given as the Leonard Hastings Schoff Lectures at Columbia University in November 2001, and four additional essays that complement and extend the analyses presented there. By combining these essays between the covers of a single volume, Chatterjee has given us a major and urgent work that provides a full perspective on the possibilities and limits of democracy in the postcolonial world.
读了第一章,即可深刻感受到中印学术界的最大差别,即在于印度寻求到一种与西方可交流的、同时又是独特的话语权。所谓“独特性”,不是将对方的嘴封上一只手,而是引导对方如何理解自己的方式。而这种理解,也不是希望对方放弃对自己的关注与思考,甚至是激发对方建立更为完整...
評分Partha Chatterjee这本书的主要论点大致可以用这一句话来概括:“除了大众主权的抽象许诺之外,大部分世界的人民正在发明新的方式,根据这种新的方式,他们可以选择他们应该如何被治理。……人民学会,同时也迫使他们的统治者学会,他们愿意怎样被统治。……这是对民主的一个好...
評分Social and political scientists have for long faced the challenge of how to apply concepts with Western derivations to the non-Western world. While earlier generations of scholars took for granted the universality of these concepts, in the past few years an...
評分政治社会的概念,确实可以用来嘲讽那些傻逼中国公知的《公民社会进行曲》,但转念一想,类似加尔各答“铁道村1号”这种组织,恐怕在我天朝早被威武城管大军铲灭荡平了吧。北京原来还有浙江村、河南村、新疆村呢,现在还真是地球村呀……
評分对于中国读者,尤其是内地读者来说,有趣的是,同是蜚声国际间的印度学人,作为政治学者的帕萨·查特杰,其声名要远远逊色于作为诺贝尔经济学奖得主的阿马蒂亚·森,无怪乎《被治理者的政治》甫一登陆,便有诸多读者惊呼不已:帕萨·查特杰是谁? 这看起来虽是一件无足轻重的小...
The Politics of the Governed 在線電子書 pdf 下載 txt下載 epub 下載 mobi 下載 2024