The Limits of Critique 在线电子书 图书标签: Theory literature critique Philosophy 英文版 理论 文学理论 文学批评/理论
发表于2024-12-30
The Limits of Critique 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2024
Hated this book
评分很遗憾,并不对此书很感冒。从头到尾很难找到一个真正能刺激神经的论点,倒是被Felski过于矫揉的文笔困扰了很久。以利科为靶子,但又不敢猛烈抨击suspicion这一概念,兜了很多圈子。总之,没有新空气。
评分Hated this book
评分重新刻画作为方法(method)和情绪(mood)的“批判”,回应并激化了晚近北美文学研究(尤其是英文系)的方法论争议。Felski针对“批判”提出的替代方案是ANT与情动理论的杂糅,关注文本作为actor如何突破历史语境的框限,并强调读者对文本的感性浸入,以取代凌驾于文本之上、抽离于文本之外的批判主体。实践上的困难在于,如何在教学中践行所谓有别于“非批判”的“后批判”,尤其是在往往以Culler“理论=批驳常识”的著名公式为前设的本科入门课上,是否有必要分辨、以及如何真正分辨“前反思”的情动(印象式议论、美文主义等)与“后批判”的情动。
评分很遗憾,并不对此书很感冒。从头到尾很难找到一个真正能刺激神经的论点,倒是被Felski过于矫揉的文笔困扰了很久。以利科为靶子,但又不敢猛烈抨击suspicion这一概念,兜了很多圈子。总之,没有新空气。
Rita Felski is William R. Kenan, Jr., Professor of English at the University of Virginia, and editor of New Literary History. Felski is a prominent scholar in the fields of aesthetics and literary theory, feminist theory, modernity and postmodernity, and cultural studies.
Felski received an honors degree in French and German literature from Cambridge University and her PhD from the Department of German at Monash University in Australia. Before coming to the University of Virginia in 1994, she taught in the Program for English and Comparative Literature at Murdoch University in Perth. She served as Chair of the Comparative Literature Program at Virginia from 2004 to 2008.
From 2003-2007 Felski served as U.S. editor of Feminist Theory. She has also served on the editorial boards of Modernism/Modernity, Modern Fiction Studies, The International Journal of Cultural Studies, Criticism, and Echo: A Music-Centered Journal. Her work has been translated into Korean, Russian, Polish, Swedish, Hungarian, Italian, Croatian, Spanish, Portuguese, and Turkish.
Why must critics unmask and demystify literary works? Why do they believe that language is always withholding some truth, that the critic’s task is to reveal the unsaid or repressed? In this book, Rita Felski examines critique, the dominant form of interpretation in literary studies, and situates it as but one method among many, a method with strong allure—but also definite limits.
Felski argues that critique is a sensibility best captured by Paul Ricoeur’s phrase “the hermeneutics of suspicion.” She shows how this suspicion toward texts forecloses many potential readings while providing no guarantee of rigorous or radical thought. Instead, she suggests, literary scholars should try what she calls “postcritical reading”: rather than looking behind a text for hidden causes and motives, literary scholars should place themselves in front of it and reflect on what it suggests and makes possible.
By bringing critique down to earth and exploring new modes of interpretation, The Limits of Critique offers a fresh approach to the relationship between artistic works and the social world.
Times Literary Supplement
“Perhaps the most ambitious reappraisal of the discipline to appear since theory’s heyday.”
Los Angeles Review of Books
“Some books are so incisive and timely that they seem inevitable. . . . The Limits of Critique is such a book. By exploring its limits, Felski frees critics from relying on critique as the gatekeeper of literary studies and offers a prescient guide to life in a postcritical world.”
Critical Inquiry
"I sense that Felski wants us to dispense with the mood of mysterious purposiveness taken with literary works and with the influence machine apparatus and its moral psychology. Therein lies the book’s greatest and most ambitious provocation: its claim that aesthetic works have nothing to hide and that there is no ghost in the machine. By admitting of this fact we may reacquire the pleasures of criticism."
Choice
“What interests Felski is the critic’s task—which is to be suspicious of what lies beneath the surface of story, and she examines the methodology required to tease out that meaning and the variety of literary and psychological tools the critic uses to do so. . . . Recommended.”
ArtsATL
“Rita Felski’s The Limits of Critique . . . argues compellingly that our critical habits have unwittingly become trapped within a range so pinched we can barely turn our heads to see that there might be other possibilities available. She offers a nuanced description of the state of theory-heavy academic literary critique, and some proposals for how we might finally start to move beyond it.”
Textual Practice
“Felski’s prose is bold and engaging throughout, and we are privy to her dexterous style which successfully surveys an expansive range of canonical and local critical narratives. . . . Painting a provocative landscape of contemporary critical practices, The Limits of Critique will undoubtedly resonate both with readers who are entrenched in the US culture that Felski describes as well as those external to it.”
American Literary History Online Review
“Felski’s punchy colloquial style eases our path . . . and her footnotes collect any number of easy-to-overlook gems . . . including not a few from the pages of New Literary History, the journal she has revived so impressively. . . . Her exasperation with the histrionics of critique and its bullying of literature is merited and persuasive.”
London Review of Books
“[A] bold, stylish new study.”
Wai Chee Dimock, Yale University
“A major theorist with a lively prose and an equally lively use of metaphor, Felski has always been where the action is. She has now written a book that will get all of us to take another look at what we’ve been doing. The Limits of Critique will shock some and elate others. No one will feel neutral, and no one can afford not to read this book.”
Mary Poovey, New York University
“Timely, well-written, and compelling. This is that rare book that offers persuasive answers to a question many literary scholars are asking today, yet also promises to open new conversations that will continue into the future. The Limits of Critique should be required reading for all lovers of literature.”
评分
评分
评分
评分
The Limits of Critique 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2024