From a universally respected combat journalist, a gripping history based on five years of front-line reporting about how the war was turned around–and the choice now facing America
During the fierce battle for Fallujah, Bing West asked an Iraqi colonel why the archterrorist Abu Musab al-Zarqawi had fled in women’s clothes. The colonel pointed to a Marine patrol walking by and said, “Americans are the strongest tribe.”
In Iraq, America made mistake after mistake. Many gave up on the war. Then the war took a sharp U-turn. Two generals–David Petraeus and Raymond Odierno–displayed the leadership America expected. Bringing the reader from the White House to the fighting in the streets, this remarkable narrative explains the turnaround by U.S. forces.
In the course of fourteen extended trips over five years, West embedded with more than sixty front-line units, discussing strategy with generals and tactics with corporals. He provides an expert’s account of counterinsurgency, disposing of myths. By describing the characters and combat in city after city, West gives the reader an in-depth understanding that will inform the debate about the war. This is the definitive study of how American soldiers actually fought –a gripping and visceral book that changes the way we think about the war, and essential reading for understanding the next critical steps to be taken.
Praise for The Strongest Tribe:
" Balanced, panoramic assessment of the Iraq War by former Marine and Reagan administration veteran West ( No True Glory , 2005, etc.), who heralds American soldiers as its unsung heroes amid the “fog of Washington”. . .A timely, eye-opening historical analysis that provides clarity around the difficult choices the next president faces."
--Kirkus (starred review)
"In this important new chronicle of the war in Iraq, Bing West reveals how America reached the brink of defeat in 2006 and then managed in 2007 to stage a stunning turnaround. With its vivid, on-the-ground reporting, his book is a fitting tribute to the honor, valor, and toughness of our soldiers. Notwithstanding numerous mistakes by their leaders, West shows that their sacrifices have made success possible--as long we do not withdraw prematurely."
--Senator John S. McCain
“Sometimes the best way to support the troops is to criticize the generals. Bing West does both well in this book, showing a sympathy for our soldiers and Marines, but also a great ear for military truth and a determination to render events accurately. This is his third and most important book about the Iraq war. Read it.”
-- Thomas E. Ricks, author of FIASCO: The American Military Adventure in Iraq
“A brilliant exposition. Based on extensive experience in the war zone, Bing West recounts how Soldiers and Marines showed the President and the Pentagon the way to solve the Iraq insurgency problem. Echoing the admonition that "all politics are local", The Strongest Tribe convincingly argues that it was a grass roots strategy developed by on-scene officers who forged ties at the tribal level that brought stability to Iraq's turbulent Anbar Province and provided hope for all Iraq.”
-- Lt. Gen. Bernard E. Trainor USMC (Ret.) Co-author of The Generals' War
and COBRA II: The Inside Story of the Invation and Occupation of Iraq
“Some four decades ago I told Bing West that his book, the Village, would become a classic in counterinsurgency warfare. And so it did. "The Strongest Tribe" will surely be West's second classic - a moving and detailed account of almost six years of war in Iraq.”
- Dr. James R. Schlesinger, Director of Central Intelligence Agency, Nixon administration; Secretary of Defense, Ford administration; Chairman, The Mitre Corporation
评分
评分
评分
评分
说实话,我属于那种对世界观构建有着近乎偏执要求的读者。太多作品在设定上漏洞百出,或者后期为了迎合读者而自我崩塌。但是,这部作品在世界观的铺陈上,展现了令人惊叹的严谨和想象力。从那些古老仪式的细节,到不同群体之间微妙的资源分配机制,一切都似乎经过了数万年的自然演化。那种宏大叙事下的历史厚重感,扑面而来。特别是对于特定文化符号的描绘,既有陌生化的处理,又保留了让人可以理解的内核,这种平衡拿捏得恰到好处。阅读过程就像是在解码一部失落的文明史,每揭开一层皮,都能看到更深层的复杂结构。我尤其喜欢作者在描述那些自然奇观时的笔法,那种雄浑壮阔,几乎让我能感受到风吹过皮肤的粗粝感。它成功地创造了一个既熟悉又完全陌生的空间,让读者可以完全沉浸其中,忘记了自己身处何地。这种沉浸式的体验,是优秀幻想文学的最高标准,而这本书,无疑达到了这个高度。
评分这部作品的文学价值是毋庸置疑的,但更让我惊喜的是它在情感传递上的强大穿透力。它没有刻意煽情,但那些关于失去、关于忠诚、关于牺牲的片段,却像一把钝刀子,缓慢而坚定地扎进心底。我很少为书中的情节而流泪,但有几个瞬间,我的呼吸都为之停滞。作者对人类脆弱性的描摹,尤其精准到位——即便是最坚韧的个体,也会在极致的痛苦面前露出人性中最柔软的部分。这种对“人性光辉与阴影”的并存描绘,让作品避免了脸谱化的危险。更重要的是,故事中关于传承和希望的主题,被处理得既悲观又充满韧性。它告诉你,即便世界崩塌,总有人会站出来,用微弱但坚定的力量去点燃下一根火柴。这种复杂的情感基调,让整个故事显得既沉重又温暖,是一种历经磨难后的升华。它不只是在讲述一个生存故事,更是在探讨我们作为人类,应该如何面对不可避免的痛苦。
评分这本书的叙事节奏简直让人欲罢不能,作者对于故事的掌控力非同一般。它不像那种平铺直叙的流水账,而是像一把精心打磨过的斧头,每一章节的推进都带着明确的目的性,精准地砍向故事的核心。我特别欣赏其中对于环境描写的细腻,那种扑面而来的真实感,让我仿佛真的置身于那个充满未知与挑战的蛮荒之地。角色之间的互动更是火花四射,他们的对话充满了潜台词和张力,你得自己去挖掘那些没有明说出来的深层含义。特别是主角的内心挣扎,那种在生存压力与道德困境之间的摇摆不定,刻画得极其立体和人性化。我很少看到一部作品能够如此深入地探讨“力量的代价”这一宏大主题,它不是简单地歌颂强大,而是深刻揭示了拥有力量后必须背负的沉重责任。每一次危机爆发,我都替主角捏一把汗,那种肾上腺素飙升的感觉,完全超越了阅读体验,更像是一场身临其境的冒险。作者的文笔老辣而富有感染力,即使用最朴素的词汇,也能构建出史诗般的画面感,让人在掩卷之后,依旧能清晰地回味起那些惊心动魄的瞬间。
评分我必须承认,起初我对这类主题的书籍抱有一定的保留态度,总觉得它们难免会落入俗套,充斥着不切实际的英雄主义。然而,这本书彻底颠覆了我的固有印象。它的魅力在于其非凡的“真实性”——这种真实并非指事件的物理可能性,而是指人物情感和动机的逻辑自洽。作者似乎对人性幽暗面的理解达到了一个令人敬畏的深度。书中对权力结构和群体心理的剖析,尖锐得让人感到一丝寒意。你看那些次要角色,他们并非仅仅是推动情节的工具人,每个人都有着自己清晰的欲望和局限性,他们的选择,无论对错,都深深植根于他们所处的环境和自身的经历之中。最让我拍案叫绝的是,作者处理冲突的方式,它很少采用一刀切的简单解决方案,更多的是复杂博弈和微妙的妥协,这使得整个故事的层次感陡然提升。读完之后,我花了很长时间去整理自己的思绪,因为它迫使我去反思许多关于组织、领导力乃至文明起源的底层逻辑。它不仅仅是一个故事,更像是一份关于生存哲学的深度报告。
评分我必须强调,这本书的叙事结构是一种极其高明的艺术呈现。它不是线性的,而是采用了多视角、甚至带有碎片化闪回的手法,但奇怪的是,这种看似零散的叙事,最终却汇集成一条清晰有力的河流。作者非常擅长运用“留白”,他不会把所有的事情都解释得清清楚楚,很多关键的转折点,都需要读者自己去填补逻辑和情感的空白。这种主动参与感,极大地增强了阅读的趣味性,让我感觉自己不是一个旁观者,而是这个世界共同的见证者和参与者。从文学技巧上讲,它对视角转换的运用简直是教科书级别的范例,每一次切换都能带来新的信息增量,同时又不会让读者感到困惑。那些看似无关紧要的细节,到最后都会以一种令人惊叹的方式,成为解开整个谜团的关键线索。这种结构上的精妙,让我在重读时,依然能发现新的层次和含义,这无疑是一部经得起反复推敲的佳作,其复杂性和深度,远超一般通俗读物。
评分 评分 评分 评分 评分本站所有内容均为互联网搜索引擎提供的公开搜索信息,本站不存储任何数据与内容,任何内容与数据均与本站无关,如有需要请联系相关搜索引擎包括但不限于百度,google,bing,sogou 等
© 2026 book.wenda123.org All Rights Reserved. 图书目录大全 版权所有