Tao Yuanming and Manuscript Culture 在线电子书 图书标签: 田晓菲 海外汉学 诗歌 陶渊明 汉学 文学 六朝 魏晋南北朝
发表于2025-02-07
Tao Yuanming and Manuscript Culture 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2025
读了很憋气的一本书:精彩的部分(藏舟)能让人击节,无语的部分(“望”/“见”之争)写得非常不好。不好的原因在于:1)田隐隐约约投射了自己的大前提(PRC喜欢创造中国性,所以宋人也喜欢塑造宋的唐及唐前性);2)文献学的部分有自相矛盾之疑,一方面过于依赖明及以后的文献学大家的推论(过于扬明抑宋,也算是独一家了),没有把她最为依赖的宋及宋前手稿部分高亮讨论;3)诗学内的讨论又过于anachronistic,过于强调共情。然而考虑到诗话在宋以前本身就不是大宗,怎么均衡对于某一个唐前文本的极度不均衡的后世评论量是一个方法论上很重要的内容,不好好说一下似乎也不妥。#总的来说就是一本总觉得有哪里不对但又不大说的上来哪里不对的奇书
评分分主题阐释了陶潜诗歌及其manuscript culture,兼含大量陶诗的分析解读。把陶诗从历史动态演变的视角来剖析,她这本是算是一次有意义的尝试。本书国内学者争议较大。
评分就是要不一样的陶渊明。觉得很好。
评分文献学和小学的功夫有欠缺,难怪在国内学界广受争议,整体架构和理论切入点受汉学研究影响很大。
评分就是要不一样的陶渊明。觉得很好。
田晓菲,1971年生人,6岁习古诗,古今中外,阅读颇丰。1985年经过北京大学英语系、心理学系、中文系老师面试,特招进入北大英语系。而当时年仅14岁的她,以与生俱来的才情和聪颖,已出版两本诗集,名动天下,真正是少年成名。时隔多年,再次出现在人们视野中的田晓菲已是执教于哈佛大学东亚系的年轻学者田晓菲了,不时有佳作问世,显示了她深厚的知识积淀。让人惊讶于她的才情之余,更惊叹于她学者的严谨与智慧,以及她勤奋踏实地走过的每一步。从北大毕业后,田晓菲远赴大洋彼岸求学,于1998年获哈佛大学比较文学博士学位,曾在美国柯盖特大学,康奈尔大学教书,现在哈佛大学任教。
As medieval Chinese manuscripts were copied and recopied through the centuries, both mistakes and deliberate editorial changes were introduced, thereby affecting readers' impressions of the author's intent. In "Tao Yuanming and Manuscript Culture", Xiaofei Tian shows how readers not only experience authors but produce them by shaping texts to their interpretation. Tian examines the mechanics and history of textual transmission in China by focusing on the evolution over the centuries of the reclusive poet Tao Yuanming into a figure of epic stature. Considered emblematic of the national character, Tao Yuanming (also known as Tao Qian, 365-427 c.e.) is admired for having turned his back on active government service and city life to live a simple rural life of voluntary poverty. The artlessness of his poetic style is held as the highest literary and moral ideal, and literary critics have taken great pains to demonstrate perfect consistency between Tao Yuanming's life and poetry.Earlier work on Tao Yuanming has tended to accept this image, interpreting the poems to confirm the image. "Tao Yuanming and Manuscript Culture" is a study of how this cultural icon was produced and of the elusive traces of another, historical Tao Yuanming behind the icon. By comparing four early biographies of the poet, Tian shows how these are in large measure constructed out of Tao Yuanming's self-image as projected in his poetry and prose. Drawing on work in European medieval literature, she demonstrates the fluidity of the Chinese medieval textual world and how its materials were historically reconfigured for later purposes. Tian finds in Tao's poetic corpus not one essentialized Tao Yuanming, but multiple texts continuously produced long after the author's physical demise.Her provocative look at the influence of manuscript culture on literary perceptions transcends its immediate subject and has special resonance today, when the transition from print to electronic media is shaking the literary world in a way not unlike the transition from handwritten to print media in medieval China.
讀過《塵几錄》,對手抄本文化和陶淵明的文學鑒賞,有了更深的瞭解。雖然還談不上研究,至少對手抄本文化現象和陶淵明的千古誤讀,有了許多新鮮的見識。其文風明白曉暢、通俗易懂,相較之下,現時許多文學研究著作曲高和寡、故作高深的理論詮釋和演繹,相反更令人如墜雲霧,不...
评分读田晓菲《尘几录》,让人很容易就想到一个历史学上的问题,即顾颉刚提出的“层累地造成的中国古史”的理论。其实,不仅中国历史,不仅陶渊明,每一个国家、每一个名人的历史,恐怕都存在着一个“层累地造成”的问题。克罗齐所谓“一切历史都是现代史”,从某种意义上说,表达...
评分草草把田教授的《尘几录》正文读完,忍不住要跑来写上两笔。一来是因为田教授治学的思路很新,陶渊明的集子版本诸多,其实早有前人潜心研究,但是把古籍版本中“手抄本”文化的概念抽出来,和陶渊明的形象扯在一起谈读者对于文本的接受与阐释,的确是让人很受启发。这的确...
评分课程作业: 经过钱钟书在《谈艺录》中的论证,“渊明在六代三唐,正以知希为贵”“渊明文名,至宋而极”,这一精到论点已经成为学者共识。在南朝时期,隐士已经相当普遍,陶渊明也仅仅是作为普通的隐逸文人受到关注。萧统编《文选》,只收入他的几首诗和《归去来兮辞》;钟嵘...
评分Tao Yuanming and Manuscript Culture 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2025