Forms 在线电子书 图书标签: theory form 比较文学 文化探讨 CriticalTheory Structuralism Formalism CulturalStudies
发表于2024-11-25
Forms 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2024
选取的文本跨度极大(从《安提戈涅》到《火线》),以朗西埃为理论前设(形式即政治,政治即形式,拒绝区分社会和美学的registers)对历史主义进行反拨,关注不同形式如何相遇、互动,并由此定位文学及文学批评自身的政治。去年PMLA有一期做了关于这本书的dossier。
评分近年学界诸多为回归"形式"张本的尝试之一。回应了二战后文学界对totality, institution等的paranoid hostility,用跨度很大的例子讨论被视作normative/oppressive的诸概念如何同时可以是productive containment。本书探讨的其实是一个老生常谈的问题,即什么样的概念是有用的。作者对form的推崇主要关注其transferability/iterability(奇妙的德里达回音,尽管作者声称要move beyond deconstruction);但讽刺的是,form/formalism同时被扩张到无限大,以致作为概念完全失去作用。远不如North那本。
评分没看过火线,所以最后的例子不太熟悉。整体思想感觉非常朗西埃,但是格局也非常狭小,workshop时作者解释了为什么,为了更多的人能加入讨论,这大概也是一种桎梏。workshop看到作者为了捍卫自己的书不停回应博士们的提问,真的感觉压力好大好紧张。北美学生的训练也由此可见一斑了。
评分Bold, ambitious, sometimes counterintuitive, and soooooo readable. 但是总感觉作者提出的这个框架有点太万金油了,仿佛什么都能往框里装并得出一个很predictable的结论。需要时间和更多实例来检验的理论宏图。
评分Bold, ambitious, sometimes counterintuitive, and soooooo readable. 但是总感觉作者提出的这个框架有点太万金油了,仿佛什么都能往框里装并得出一个很predictable的结论。需要时间和更多实例来检验的理论宏图。
Forms offers a powerful new answer to one of the most pressing problems facing literary, critical, and cultural studies today--how to connect form to political, social, and historical context. Caroline Levine argues that forms organize not only works of art but also political life--and our attempts to know both art and politics. Inescapable and frequently troubling, forms shape every aspect of our experience. But forms don't impose their order in any simple way. Multiple shapes, patterns, and arrangements, overlapping and colliding, generate complex and unpredictable social landscapes that challenge and unsettle conventional analytic models in literary and cultural studies.
Borrowing the concept of "affordances" from design theory, this book investigates the specific ways that four major forms--wholes, rhythms, hierarchies, and networks--have structured culture, politics, and scholarly knowledge across periods, and it proposes exciting new ways of linking formalism to historicism and literature to politics. Levine rereads both formalist and antiformalist theorists, including Cleanth Brooks, Michel Foucault, Jacques Rancière, Mary Poovey, and Judith Butler, and she offers engaging accounts of a wide range of objects, from medieval convents and modern theme parks to Sophocles's Antigone and the television series The Wire.
The result is a radically new way of thinking about form for the next generation and essential reading for scholars and students across the humanities who must wrestle with the problem of form and context.
评分
评分
评分
评分
Forms 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2024