具体描述
作者简介
目录信息
读后感
评分
评分
评分
评分
用户评价
“Externalism and the Mental”——这个书名简洁而有力，直接点明了心灵哲学领域中最具影响力和争议性的主题之一。作为一个热衷于探索人类心智奥秘的读者，我对这本书充满了期待，因为“心灵外在主义”（Externalism）的出现，彻底改变了我们对思想内容、指称和意义的理解方式。我非常希望这本书能够清晰地呈现外在主义的核心论证，特别是它如何通过强调“含义的延伸”（the extension of meaning）来挑战内在主义（Internalism）的观点，即心智内容完全由颅内状态决定。我期待书中能详细介绍诸如克里普克（Kripke）的“命名词的指称理论”（theory of reference for proper names）和普特南（Putnam）的“含义是外部的”（meaning is external）等关键论点，以及这些论点如何被用来解释我们对世界的感知和理解。Moreover, a significant part of my anticipation lies in the book's potential to explore the implications of externalism for our understanding of consciousness and intentionality. If the content of our thoughts is intertwined with the external world, what does this imply about the subjective experience of being a thinking subject? How does externalism account for the qualitative aspects of mental states? I am eager to see how the author navigates these complex questions, offering insights into the nature of subjective experience and the mechanisms by which our minds engage with and are shaped by the external environment, ultimately providing a more comprehensive picture of what it means to have a mind.
评分《Externalism and the Mental》这本书的书名，在我看来，直击了现代心灵哲学中最具争议但也最有启发性的议题之一。我对心灵外在主义（Externalism）的兴趣由来已久，尤其是在我读到像“双子地球”（Twin Earth）这样的思想实验时，对我们自身心智内容的界定方式产生了深刻的疑问。这本书的标题暗示着它将对这一理论进行系统性的阐述和分析，我迫不及待地想知道它会如何构建关于“外在性”（externality）与“心智”（mental）之间关系的论证。我想，这本书的核心任务之一，必然是清晰地阐释外在主义如何挑战了那些认为心智内容完全由颅内状态决定的“内在主义”（Internalism）的观点。它或许会详细介绍诸如“含义是外部的”（meaning is external）的论断，以及这种论断如何延伸到其他心智状态，例如信念、愿望和知觉。我非常期待这本书能够深入探讨外在主义在处理“指称”（reference）和“意义”（meaning）这些基本语言和思想单位时的具体机制，以及它如何解释我们如何能够拥有关于特定对象或属性的特定思想。The book’s title suggests a deep dive into the metaphysical underpinnings of mental content, and I am particularly interested in how it will address the conceptual challenges that arise from this externalist framework. For instance, how do we account for the apparent subjective feel of our mental states if their content is, in part, determined by factors outside of our direct mental access? This question, central to the philosophy of mind, is one I hope this book tackles with rigor and clarity, offering new perspectives on the relationship between our inner lives and the objective world we inhabit.
评分当我第一次瞥见《Externalism and the Mental》这本书的书名时，我的思维立刻被它的深度和广度所吸引。作为一个长期关注心灵哲学议题的读者，我深知“心灵外在主义”（Externalism）这一理论在当代哲学讨论中的核心地位。它不仅仅是对传统“心灵内在主义”（Internalism）的一种挑战，更是一种深刻的重塑，试图将我们对心智的理解从孤立的颅内空间解放出来，重新安置于更为广阔的社会、物理及文化语境之中。我非常好奇这本书将如何构建其论证框架，它是否会从历史的维度出发，追溯外在主义思想的源头，例如从早期关于指称（reference）和意义（meaning）的讨论，一直到20世纪后半叶，由希拉里·普特南（Hilary Putnam）的“孪生地球”（Twin Earth）思想实验所引发的革命性进展。我同样期待它能够深入探讨外在主义在不同心智领域中的具体应用，比如关于信念（belief）、欲望（desire）、感知（perception）、记忆（memory）以及语言理解（language understanding）等方面的解释。这本书的成功之处，我想一定在于它能否清晰地阐明外在主义理论的核心论证，例如，它如何界定“外部因素”的范畴，以及这些外部因素是如何具体地塑造和构成我们的心智状态的。Moreover, I anticipate a thorough examination of the implications of externalism for our understanding of knowledge, rationality, and even personal identity. The idea that what I think might depend on facts about the external world that I am not even consciously aware of is a fascinating and potentially unsettling consequence of this philosophical stance, and I am eager to explore how the book navigates these intricate philosophical waters.
评分这本书名“Externalism and the Mental”本身就激发起了一连串的哲学思考，让我对接下来的阅读充满了期待。我一直对心灵的本质，特别是它与外部世界的关系感到好奇。哲学领域中，“心灵外在主义”（Externalism）作为一个重要的学派，其核心观点——即我们心灵状态的意义和内容在很大程度上由我们所处的外部环境决定，而非仅仅由我们头脑中的内部状态所决定——一直是我深入探讨的焦点。这本书的标题直接点出了这个主题，让我相信它会为我提供一个全面且深入的视角来理解这一复杂而又至关重要的哲学概念。我希望这本书能够梳理清楚心灵外在主义的各种理论，比如克里普克（Kripke）的因果理论，德雷茨克（Dretske）的“信息传输”模型，以及福多（Fodor）的“功能主义”解释，等等。更重要的是，我期待这本书能够清晰地阐述这些理论之间的异同，以及它们在解释心灵现象时所面临的挑战和争议。例如，关于“含义的延伸”（the extension of meaning）的论证，以及它们如何解释“意向性”（intentionality）和“意识”（consciousness）等核心心灵属性，都是我非常感兴趣的方面。Furthermore, I'm keen to see how the book addresses the potential criticisms of externalism, such as the problem of semantic indeterminacy or the challenge posed by radical skepticism. The very idea that my thoughts, beliefs, and desires are not solely contained within the confines of my skull, but are inseparably linked to the world around me, is both exhilarating and a little disorienting. It suggests a profound interconnectedness between the individual mind and the external reality, a notion that resonates deeply with my own intuitive understanding of how we navigate and make sense of our existence.
评分“Externalism and the Mental”——这个书名本身就散发着一股强大的哲学力量，精准地命中了心灵哲学领域中的一个核心冲突点。作为一个对此领域抱有极大热情的研究者，我深信这本书将为我提供一个全新的视角来审视我们对心智的理解。心灵外在主义（Externalism）的兴起，无疑是对传统哲学观念的一次深刻颠覆，它将心智的边界从孤立的个体大脑扩展到更广阔的社会和物理环境。我希望这本书能够系统地梳理外在主义的核心论点，特别是它如何通过一系列精巧的论证，例如关于“含义的延展性”（semantic extension）的观点，来证明心智内容不能仅仅依靠内部的、与物理世界无关的状态来完全定义。我特别期待看到这本书如何解释“指称”（reference）和“意义”（meaning）的外部决定性，以及这种外部性如何具体地影响到我们的信念、愿望以及其他的意向性（intentional）状态。Moreover, I am eager to see how the book navigates the complex landscape of criticisms leveled against externalism. Theories that locate the determinants of mental content in the external world are often met with challenges regarding our introspective access to our own minds, the possibility of radical skepticism about the external world, and the very nature of mental causation. A comprehensive treatment of these objections, and the potential responses offered by various externalist positions, will be crucial for understanding the robustness and limitations of this influential philosophical approach. The promise of a thorough and nuanced exploration of these foundational questions makes this book a highly anticipated read for anyone invested in the philosophy of mind.
评分《Externalism and the Mental》这本书的书名，对我来说，是一个充满哲学魅力的邀约，邀请我去深入探索心智的本质及其与外部世界的复杂关系。我一直对“心灵外在主义”（Externalism）所提出的观点深感着迷，即我们思想的内容不仅仅取决于我们大脑内部的状态，还受到我们所处的社会、物理以及语言环境的影响。这本书的标题精准地概括了这一核心议题，我期待它能为我提供一个系统且深入的理解框架，帮助我把握外在主义如何在挑战传统“内在主义”（Internalism）观点的同时，构建起一套全新的心智理论。我非常希望书中能够详尽地阐述外在主义的核心论证，特别是它如何通过“含义的延伸”（the extension of meaning）这一概念，来证明我们思想的意义和内容，在很大程度上是由外部世界所决定的。Furthermore, I am particularly keen to understand the epistemological implications of externalism. If the content of our thoughts is partly determined by factors outside of our direct conscious awareness, does this mean we might misunderstand our own mental states? How does externalism reconcile this with our intuitive sense of self-knowledge? These are profound questions that lie at the heart of philosophy of mind, and I am eager to see how this book tackles these intricate issues, offering a nuanced and comprehensive analysis that will undoubtedly challenge my assumptions and deepen my appreciation for the subtle and complex ways in which our minds engage with and are shaped by the world around us.
评分《Externalism and the Mental》这个书名，对我而言，不仅仅是一个标签，更是一种承诺，承诺着对心智领域最前沿、最深刻的议题的深入探讨。我一直对“心灵外在主义”（Externalism）的论证及其对我们理解自身心智的革命性影响感到着迷。这本书的标题精准地概括了这一核心主题，我期待它能提供一个全面而深入的导览，帮助我理解外在主义如何挑战了那些将心智内容完全局限于个体颅内状态的“内在主义”（Internalism）观点。我希望书中能够详细阐述外在主义如何通过诸如“含义的延伸”（the extension of meaning）等关键概念，来证明我们思想的意义和内容，在很大程度上是由我们所处的外部环境所决定的。Furthermore, a critical aspect I'm looking forward to is how the book will tackle the implications of externalism for our understanding of mental causation and intentionality. If the content of our thoughts is tied to the external world, how do our thoughts cause actions? Does this external connection alter our understanding of free will or responsibility? These are profound questions that have far-reaching consequences, and I am eager to see how the author connects the dots between externalist semantics and the broader landscape of mental phenomena, providing a comprehensive and insightful analysis that will undoubtedly enrich my philosophical toolkit and deepen my appreciation for the complex architecture of the human mind.
评分“Externalism and the Mental”——仅仅是这个书名，就足以激起我内心深处对心灵哲学的好奇心和探索欲。自从我第一次接触到“心灵外在主义”（Externalism）的概念，我就被它所提出的深刻洞见所吸引：我们头脑中的思想和信念，并非完全是我们颅内物理状态的产物，而是与外部世界紧密相连，甚至在某种程度上是由外部世界决定的。这本书的标题精确地抓住了这一核心命题，我期待它能为我提供一个全面而深入的分析，阐明外在主义如何颠覆了传统的心灵哲学观念。我尤其希望看到书中能够详细解释外在主义的核心论证，例如“含义是外部的”（meaning is external）这一重要观点，以及它如何通过“语义外部性”（semantic externalism）的理论来解释我们对世界的理解和认知。Moreover, I am particularly interested in how the book addresses the potential criticisms and challenges faced by externalist theories. For instance, how does externalism account for our seemingly direct introspective access to our own mental states? If the content of my thought depends on external factors I may not be aware of, how can I be sure I know what I am thinking? These epistemological questions are crucial for a complete understanding of externalism, and I am eager to see how the author navigates these complex issues, offering insightful arguments and potential resolutions that will expand my philosophical horizons and deepen my appreciation for the intricate relationship between our inner mental lives and the external world.
评分《Externalism and the Mental》这个书名，对任何一个对心灵哲学有深入了解的人来说，都无疑是一记振聋发聩的号角，预示着一场关于我们心智本质的深刻探索。我对“心灵外在主义”（Externalism）的着迷，源于它所提出的“含义的延展性”（semantic extensibility）这一革命性概念，这一概念挑战了那种认为思想内容完全受制于我们颅内状态的传统观点。这本书的标题精准地抓住了这一核心议题，我预期它将为我们深入理解这一理论提供一个极其全面且富有洞察力的导览。我期待它能够详细阐释外在主义如何在解释“指称”（reference）、“意义”（meaning）以及其他意向性（intentionality）概念时，将焦点从内部状态转向外部环境。诸如“双子地球”（Twin Earth）思想实验的经典案例，以及它如何揭示我们关于“水”的认知内容与普通地球上的认知内容大相径庭，是我特别希望能在这本书中看到详细分析的。Furthermore, I am keen to understand how externalism addresses fundamental questions about mental causation and epistemological access. If the content of our thoughts is partly determined by the external world, how does this affect our ability to know our own minds? Does it imply that we might be mistaken about the content of our own thoughts without realizing it? These are intricate issues that require careful philosophical argumentation, and I am optimistic that this book will provide robust answers and stimulate further debate on these critical points, thereby enriching my understanding of the intricate relationship between the mind and the world.
评分《Externalism and the Mental》这本书的标题，如同一扇开启哲学思辨大门的钥匙，直接指向了我们理解心智的根本性问题。作为一名长期关注心灵哲学发展趋势的读者，我深知“心灵外在主义”（Externalism）在近年来引起的巨大反响，它挑战了长期以来占据主导地位的“内在主义”（Internalism）观点，即认为心智状态的内容完全由个体内部状态决定。我期待这本书能够系统地梳理和阐述外在主义的核心论证，特别是它如何通过“语义外部性”（semantic externalism）的论断，即我们思想和语言的意义在很大程度上由外部世界所决定，来重塑我们对心智的理解。我尤其感兴趣的是，这本书会如何解释外在主义如何处理“指称”（reference）和“意义”（meaning）的问题，以及这些概念的外部决定性如何具体地体现在我们的信念、感知和记忆等心智活动中。Moreover, I am particularly interested in how the book will address the epistemological challenges posed by externalism. If the content of our thoughts is partly determined by factors in the external world that we may not fully grasp or be aware of, what does this imply about our knowledge of our own minds? Can we be certain about the content of our own beliefs? This philosophical puzzle is one that I hope this book will tackle with intellectual rigor, providing a nuanced analysis of how externalism affects our understanding of self-knowledge and our ability to ascertain the true nature of our mental states, thus offering a fresh perspective on the intricate interplay between our inner world and the external reality.
评分 评分 评分 评分 评分相关图书
本站所有内容均为互联网搜索引擎提供的公开搜索信息，本站不存储任何数据与内容，任何内容与数据均与本站无关，如有需要请联系相关搜索引擎包括但不限于百度，google,bing,sogou 等
© 2026 book.wenda123.org All Rights Reserved. 图书目录大全 版权所有