The Interrogation Rooms of the Korean War 在线电子书 图书标签: 历史 东亚史 War Korean
发表于2024-11-26
The Interrogation Rooms of the Korean War 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2024
用的材料是够多了。但是个体的案例和宏观的结论中间存在着巨大的“统计学上无意义”的gap。
评分用的材料是够多了。但是个体的案例和宏观的结论中间存在着巨大的“统计学上无意义”的gap。
评分关注战争中普通人的心路与面对战争和政治暴力的反应、韩战是韩半岛主体性树立并拆解新(美国)老(日本)帝国的压缩、战俘营事件和审讯室互动体现不同的政治项目都能理解,但写作极其碎片化,满嘴“主体性”却又在细节史料中暴力插入理论大词自由心证,谈绑架杜德准将突然来段洗澡的身体政治、美军战俘彰显雄性气概对抗基佬气质中国审问官、韩国人战俘必定带着反日本殖民遗产被审讯、“哇原来战俘血书在国家档案馆跟肯尼迪老婆的血裙子放一起哦”之类仿佛小孩子炫玩具的懵逼桥段比比皆是,且似乎彻底无视中朝军队政工体系,导致对诸如“共军战俘暴力手段比反共战俘更有组织”“中朝对美战俘系统性政治教育鼓动”过分惊讶,联想到作者做本书讲座时的嬉笑表现,只能说除了档案整理,就“学术审美”(如果这词真有意义)而言张泽石等回忆材料都比此书可读。
评分用的材料是够多了。但是个体的案例和宏观的结论中间存在着巨大的“统计学上无意义”的gap。
评分关注战争中普通人的心路与面对战争和政治暴力的反应、韩战是韩半岛主体性树立并拆解新(美国)老(日本)帝国的压缩、战俘营事件和审讯室互动体现不同的政治项目都能理解,但写作极其碎片化,满嘴“主体性”却又在细节史料中暴力插入理论大词自由心证,谈绑架杜德准将突然来段洗澡的身体政治、美军战俘彰显雄性气概对抗基佬气质中国审问官、韩国人战俘必定带着反日本殖民遗产被审讯、“哇原来战俘血书在国家档案馆跟肯尼迪老婆的血裙子放一起哦”之类仿佛小孩子炫玩具的懵逼桥段比比皆是,且似乎彻底无视中朝军队政工体系,导致对诸如“共军战俘暴力手段比反共战俘更有组织”“中朝对美战俘系统性政治教育鼓动”过分惊讶,联想到作者做本书讲座时的嬉笑表现,只能说除了档案整理,就“学术审美”(如果这词真有意义)而言张泽石等回忆材料都比此书可读。
Monica Kim is assistant professor of history at New York University. She lives in New York City.
A groundbreaking look at how the interrogation rooms of the Korean War set the stage for a new kind of battle—not over land but over human subjects
Traditional histories of the Korean War have long focused on violations of the thirty-eighth parallel, the line drawn by American and Soviet officials in 1945 dividing the Korean peninsula. But The Interrogation Rooms of the Korean War presents an entirely new narrative, shifting the perspective from the boundaries of the battlefield to inside the interrogation room. Upending conventional notions of what we think of as geographies of military conflict, Monica Kim demonstrates how the Korean War evolved from a fight over territory to one over human interiority and the individual human subject, forging the template for the US wars of intervention that would predominate during the latter half of the twentieth century and beyond.
Kim looks at how, during the armistice negotiations, the United States and their allies proposed a new kind of interrogation room: one in which POWs could exercise their “free will” and choose which country they would go to after the ceasefire. The global controversy that erupted exposed how interrogation rooms had become a flashpoint for the struggles between the ambitions of empire and the demands for decolonization, as the aim of interrogation was to produce subjects who attested to a nation’s right to govern. The complex web of interrogators and prisoners—Japanese-American interrogators, Indian military personnel, Korean POWs and interrogators, and American POWs—that Kim uncovers contradicts the simple story in US popular memory of “brainwashing” during the Korean War.
Bringing together a vast range of sources that track two generations of people moving between three continents, The Interrogation Rooms of the Korean War delves into an essential yet overlooked aspect of modern warfare in the twentieth century.
评分
评分
评分
评分
The Interrogation Rooms of the Korean War 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2024