The Politics of Mourning in Early China 在线电子书 图书标签: 经学 潛水 漢代 海外中国研究 历史学 中国史 中国古代史 中古史
发表于2024-11-07
The Politics of Mourning in Early China 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2024
作者的基本观点是从战国到东汉,用来象征“私情-公义”对立的符号从“父-君”变成了“母-父”,认为这个变化可以用来反驳韦伯以来的汉学对儒家官僚制始终是“君父一体”的判断。对“移孝作忠”问题的诸多经学讨论基本被她用历史演化三言两语就解释没了。另一个问题是很多材料都解读得牵强,第三章对《白虎通》关键论据的解读明显是误读。
评分最後一章關於宋代對漢代的再發現幾近胡說。通過對歐陽修片章隻語的解讀來回應一個千百年來討論已久的大問題,卻毫無任何相關回顧。這種「漢學」無知到了令人發指的地步。看在前面關於漢代碑銘中「孝道--女性」的分梳還有一絲可取之處,勉強給個兩星。
评分最後一章關於宋代對漢代的再發現幾近胡說。通過對歐陽修片章隻語的解讀來回應一個千百年來討論已久的大問題,卻毫無任何相關回顧。這種「漢學」無知到了令人發指的地步。看在前面關於漢代碑銘中「孝道--女性」的分梳還有一絲可取之處,勉強給個兩星。
评分毁瘠在汉代就有了呢,啧啧,个表演欲~
评分作者的基本观点是从战国到东汉,用来象征“私情-公义”对立的符号从“父-君”变成了“母-父”,认为这个变化可以用来反驳韦伯以来的汉学对儒家官僚制始终是“君父一体”的判断。对“移孝作忠”问题的诸多经学讨论基本被她用历史演化三言两语就解释没了。另一个问题是很多材料都解读得牵强,第三章对《白虎通》关键论据的解读明显是误读。
MIRANDA BROWN is Assistant Professor of Asian Languages and Cultures
at the University of Michigan at Ann Arbor. She is the coauthor
(with Conrad Schirokauer) of A Brief History of Chinese Civilization,
Second Edition.
2006-2007: National Endowment of the Humanities Faculty Fellowships
($40,000)
2005-2006: Chiang Ching-kuo Junior Scholar Grant ($20,000)
2005: Institute for Humanities Summer Collaborative Grant ($15,000)
2003 Rackham Spring/Summer 2003 Research Grant ($5,000)
2001-2002 Graduate Opportunity Dissertation Fellowship
2001 U.C. Berkeley Regent Fellow
2000-2001 Liu Graduate Research Fellowship in Chinese Studies
2000-2001 Foreign Language and Area Studies Fellowship
2000 Visiting Fellow, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, Beijing, P.R.C.
2000 Graduate Teaching Award
1999 Summer Mellon Dissertation and Prospectus Fellowship
1998 Summer Foreign Language and Area Studies Fellowship
1997-1999 Graduate Opportunity Fellowship
The Politics of Mourning in Early China
reevaluates the longstanding assumptions about early imperial political
culture. According to most explanations, fi lial piety served as the
linchpin of the social and political order, as all political relations were
a seamless extension of the relationship between father and son—a
relationship that was hierarchical, paternalistic, and personal. Offering a
new perspective on the mourning practices and funerary monuments
of the Han dynasty, Miranda Brown asks whether the early imperial
elite did in fact imagine political participation solely along the lines of
the father-son relationship or whether there were alternative visions
of political association. The early imperial elite held remarkably
varied and contradictory beliefs about political life, and they had
multiple templates and changing scripts for political action. This book
documents and explains such diversity and variation and shows that the
Han dynasty practice of mourning expressed many visions of political
life, visions that left lasting legacies.
“Brown’s book is a careful study that masterfully engages its sources:
commemorative inscriptions of the Eastern Han dynasty. Not content
to accept previous generalizations about these sources, she rereads
them with a critical eye and shows that Eastern Han men had a much
broader conception of political association and service than previously
thought. By looking closely at Eastern Han epitaphs and not being
beholden to any previous assumptions about them, Brown successfully
throws doubt on many conventional explanations of these documents.”
— Keith Nathaniel Knapp, author of Selfl ess Offspring: Filial Children
and Social Order in Medieval China
评分
评分
评分
评分
The Politics of Mourning in Early China 在线电子书 pdf 下载 txt下载 epub 下载 mobi 下载 2024