Plato stands as the fount of our philosophical tradition, being the first Western thinker to produce a body of writing that touches upon a wide range of topics still discussed by philosophers today. In a sense he invented philosophy as a distinct subject, for although many of these topics were discussed by his intellectual predecessors and contemporaries, he was the first to bring them together by giving them a unitary treatment. This volume contains fourteen new essays discussing Plato's views about knowledge, reality, mathematics, politics, ethics, love, poetry, and religion. There are also analyses of the intellectual and social background of his thought, the development of his philosophy throughout his career, the range of alternative approaches to his work, and the stylometry of his writing.
p13 The Forms are not a mere aggregate of abstract objects,but are in some way connected to each other;They form an ordered kosmos and therefore each must be studied not in isolation fro others but as a member of a unified whole. 对所谓的隐秘写作的驳斥不虚...
评分p13 The Forms are not a mere aggregate of abstract objects,but are in some way connected to each other;They form an ordered kosmos and therefore each must be studied not in isolation fro others but as a member of a unified whole. 对所谓的隐秘写作的驳斥不虚...
评分p13 The Forms are not a mere aggregate of abstract objects,but are in some way connected to each other;They form an ordered kosmos and therefore each must be studied not in isolation fro others but as a member of a unified whole. 对所谓的隐秘写作的驳斥不虚...
评分p13 The Forms are not a mere aggregate of abstract objects,but are in some way connected to each other;They form an ordered kosmos and therefore each must be studied not in isolation fro others but as a member of a unified whole. 对所谓的隐秘写作的驳斥不虚...
评分p13 The Forms are not a mere aggregate of abstract objects,but are in some way connected to each other;They form an ordered kosmos and therefore each must be studied not in isolation fro others but as a member of a unified whole. 对所谓的隐秘写作的驳斥不虚...
翻开这本书的扉页,首先映入眼帘的是那种熟悉的剑桥系出版物的严谨感,封面设计沉稳大气,一看就知道是为严肃的学术研究者准备的“硬货”。我原本以为这会是一本枯燥的哲学导论,毕竟柏拉图的名头太大了,似乎所有能说的都已经被前人说尽了。然而,深入阅读后我发现,它更像是一张精心绘制的、通往柏拉图思想迷宫的地图。这本书的叙事方式并非线性的,它没有试图用一个宏大的框架来“总结”柏拉图,而是像一位技艺精湛的策展人,将柏拉图思想的不同侧面——从早期的对话风格到晚期的形而上学转向——巧妙地并置在一起。阅读过程中,我时常需要停下来,回溯前文,因为作者们对特定术语(比如“理型”、“摹仿”)的细致考辨,远超我以往接触的任何入门读物。这迫使我不再满足于对柏拉图理论的表面理解,而是开始探究其在不同历史语境中的细微差别和内在矛盾。它不是直接告诉你柏拉图“说了什么”,而是告诉你“我们如何理解柏拉图所说的”,这种元认知层面的引导,对于真正想进入柏拉图思想核心的读者来说,价值无可估量。
评分如果说有什么是这本书清晰传达出来的共同基调,那就是对柏拉图文本“复杂性”的敬畏。它没有简单化柏拉图的任何一个核心概念,反而像是将它们拆解成无数个微小的碎片,让你看清每个碎片是如何被精心打磨和放置的。我尤其欣赏作者们对柏拉图“拒绝书写”这一行为的深入探讨——这种对口头传统的坚持,反过来如何影响了我们对书面文本的解读?这种后设的(meta-level)思考贯穿始终。这本书的价值在于,它不仅是对柏拉图思想本身的介绍,更是对“如何研究柏拉图”这一方法的深刻展示。它教导读者去留意那些被忽略的细节,去质疑那些看似理所当然的解释。总而言之,这不是一本用来轻松阅读的书,它更像是一块精密的试金石,衡量着读者对古典哲学严肃钻研的决心与能力。读完后,你不会觉得自己“掌握了”柏拉图,但你一定会觉得自己“学会了如何面对”柏拉图。
评分坦率地说,对于初次接触柏拉图的读者,这本书的门槛可能偏高,甚至可以说有些“不近人情”。它的语言风格是典型的、高密度的学术英语,充满了大量的专业术语和复杂的从句结构,没有为“小白”读者预留太多缓冲地带。我感觉自己不是在读一本“伴侣”,而是在旁听一场顶尖学者之间的学术辩论会,每隔几页就需要查阅一遍古典文献或术语辞典。然而,一旦你适应了这种节奏,你会发现它提供的知识密度是惊人的。特别是在讨论柏拉图的“未言之教”(unwritten doctrines)以及他对辩证法(dialectic)的实践性界定时,作者们展现了惊人的洞察力,他们有效地梳理了那些隐藏在对话文本背后的、难以捉摸的教学实践。这种深入挖掘的努力,让那些看似已经被定论的柏拉图主题,重新变得充满争议和探索的价值。对于那些希望超越标准柏拉图哲学课程的学生来说,这本书是升级装备的关键一步。
评分这本书的编排结构非常独特,它更像是一系列高质量的学术研讨会的记录合集,而非统一口径的教科书。每一章都由一位在特定领域有深厚造诣的学者撰写,这导致了风格上的显著跳跃,但正是这种差异性,构建了一个多维度的柏拉图形象。有的章节对《理想国》中正义观的社会政治意涵进行了细致入微的解构,几乎是逐句分析其内在的伦理张力;而紧接着的下一章,可能就会转向对柏拉图晚期宇宙论的考察,专注于《提玛酉斯》中数学与实在的关系,这种视角切换之快,需要读者具备高度的适应性。我尤其欣赏其中几位作者对柏拉图思想的“再语境化”尝试,他们不满足于将柏拉图视为一个孤立的古代思想家,而是积极地将他的概念与后世的哲学流派(无论是新柏拉图主义还是后来的分析哲学)进行对话。这种跨时代的比较,极大地拓宽了柏拉图理论的应用边界,让这位两千多年前的哲人再次焕发出令人兴奋的当代相关性。
评分阅读体验的差异性,很大程度上取决于你对柏拉图研究现状的了解程度。如果你对“柏拉图的统一性问题”(the unity of Plato’s thought)已经有所耳闻,那么这本书无疑是针对这一核心争议的一次精彩巡礼。不同作者代表了不同的学派立场:有的倾向于将柏拉图视为一个系统性的理论家,试图在不同对话中构建一个连贯的形而上学体系;而另一些则更侧重于柏拉图文本的文学性和戏剧性,强调对话中人物和语境对最终“意义”的塑造作用。我特别喜欢这种“不和解的张力”——它没有试图提供一个和稀泥的“官方”解释,而是将主要的学术分歧清晰地展示出来。这迫使读者必须积极参与到论证过程中去,自己去权衡哪种解读更具说服力。这种鼓励批判性参与而非被动接受的写作态度,是这部作品最宝贵的遗产之一,它成功地将一个静态的哲学偶像,转化成了一个动态的、仍在持续被阐释和争论的对象。
评分只读了极小一部分,这算自欺欺人么。
评分只读了极小一部分,这算自欺欺人么。
评分只读了极小一部分,这算自欺欺人么。
评分只读了极小一部分,这算自欺欺人么。
评分只读了极小一部分,这算自欺欺人么。
本站所有内容均为互联网搜索引擎提供的公开搜索信息,本站不存储任何数据与内容,任何内容与数据均与本站无关,如有需要请联系相关搜索引擎包括但不限于百度,google,bing,sogou 等
© 2026 book.wenda123.org All Rights Reserved. 图书目录大全 版权所有