Crazy Like Us 在線電子書 圖書標籤: 心理學 人類學 社會學 美國 文化 英文原版 精神病學 文化研究
發表於2024-12-22
Crazy Like Us 在線電子書 pdf 下載 txt下載 epub 下載 mobi 下載 2024
typical American-ego
評分作者當然是有立場的,但全書的定調努力實事求是。因吾輩非受西方文明教化長大,環顧四周,能發現更多文化環境與心理健康之間的相互影響與關係。問題是,在全球一體化的時代下,在諸如社會心理學這種領域內,如何求同存異,卻是相當復雜的。作者最後也是無解。
評分評個三星半吧。讀到後麵實在有點不耐煩,因為重復性太強瞭。作者的主要觀點在一開始就已經錶達齣來瞭,感覺整本書都在用故事來支持他的觀點。作者用敘述故事的手法也可能正是為瞭增強內容的可讀性。 人所處的社會文化不僅會影響人對精神疾病的感受(比如東方人提供更多生理癥狀,而西方人更多心理癥狀)而且也會影響社會對某種疾病或者癥狀的接受程度。作者先是譴責瞭美國精神疾病學傢在傳播專業知識上的盲目和偏見,其次又指齣瞭西方藥物對其他文化環境中的精神病人微乎其微的作用。但就像作者在結尾提齣的那樣,美國精神病學傢也隻是用他們的知識在救人,而不是再害人,也許他們的人道主義精神多少能夠彌補一些他們激進的知識轟炸吧。
評分采訪人類學傢的記者
評分typical American-ego
Ethan Watters is a free lance journalist whose work has appeared in the New York Times Magazine, Discover, Men's Journal, Spin, Details, and Wired. A frequent contributor to NPR, Watters' work appeared in the 2007 and 2008 Best American Science and Nature Writing. He co-founded the San Francisco Writers Grotto, a work space for local artists. He lives in San Francisco with his wife and children.
From Publishers Weekly:
If you thought McDonald's and strip malls were the ugliest of America's cultural exports, think again. Western ideas about mental illness-from anorexia to post-traumatic stress disorder, schizophrenia, general anxiety and clinical depression-as well as Western treatments have been sweeping the globe with alarming speed, argues journalist Watters (Urban Tribes), and are doing far more damage than Big Macs and the Gap. In this well-traveled, deeply reported book, Watters takes readers from Hong Kong to Zanzibar, to Tsunami ravaged Sri Lanka, to illustrate how distinctly American psychological disorders have played in far-off locales, and how Western treatments, from experimental, unproven drugs to talk therapy, have clashed with local customs, understandings and religions. While the book emphasizes anthropological findings at the occasional expense of medical context, and at times skitters into a broad indictment of drug companies and Western science, Watters builds a powerful case. He argues convincingly that cultural differences belie any sort of western template for diagnosing and treating mental illness, and that the rapid spread of American culture threatens our very understanding of the human mind: "We should worry about the loss of diversity in the world's differing conceptions of treatments for mental illness in the same way we worry about the loss of biodiversity in nature."
作者并不是想说本土的疗法都有效,也不是否定美式心理治疗的付出和作用。他提醒的是“他们跟我们不同”,每种文化都有自己表达痛苦的症状池,正是这些不同的心—身症状,反映了独特的个体痛苦。美式心理治疗和大制药公司的全球化推广,不免遮蔽了各种文化下个体的冲突方式。在...
評分无意间被安利的一本书,本着想要换个角度看问题的心买了,简直是一路惊呼:卧槽,读完。 心理疾病是否具有普世性?在这个全球化巨变的时代,我们飞速的接收着西方所谓的优势知识传播。可是心理的建设发展与个人所处的社会环境,民族意识甚至是区域环境都有着密切的关系。一些刚...
評分 評分作者并不是想说本土的疗法都有效,也不是否定美式心理治疗的付出和作用。他提醒的是“他们跟我们不同”,每种文化都有自己表达痛苦的症状池,正是这些不同的心—身症状,反映了独特的个体痛苦。美式心理治疗和大制药公司的全球化推广,不免遮蔽了各种文化下个体的冲突方式。在...
Crazy Like Us 在線電子書 pdf 下載 txt下載 epub 下載 mobi 下載 2024